We need to get this stopped now by writing our governor, Congressmen and senators. They OWN our debt and thus, US! Through GSGP, the Governors and Premiers work as equal partners to grow the regions $6 trillion economies and protect the worlds largest surface freshwater system. We refer to the reference definition of stealing as defined by Webster as to appropriate to oneself or beyond ones proper share. Nestle is taking advantage of Michigans $200 permit to offer farmers the ability to pump groundwater for irrigation, not for selling. Unchanged Mission: Activists say a Nestle Great Lakes exit doesn't automatically. (btw great photo!). Is it stealing Great Lakes water? Manage Settings As of September 2015 Michigan is, indeed, the only such state, despite the best efforts of Wisconsins republican governor, Scott Walker. This water shortage is causing massive problems all over the state. Lisa Borre is a lake conservationist, freelance writer, and avid sailor. The request for an economic discussion will obfuscate the serious national security risk that water diversion poses. what about this thero China is stealing our jobs and seling the products to wals marts. you can help us dredge our dock again next summer. I still think this would work and solve many problems! I'm not disagreeing water levels are currently down -. There is no question that lake temperatures are warming and winter ice cover is decreasing. The city of Waukesha in June 2016 was approved to divert water from Lake Michigan for its drinking water supply after eight representatives from the states that border the Great Lakes voted unanimously to allow the diversion. Great Lakes. The views expressed in this article are those of the author alone and not the World Economic Forum. China stealing/ taking the Great Lakes water, then selling it back to Here is the Truth. Moreover, it makes neither environmental nor Great Lakes-aligned economic sense to further consumer demand by irrigating an historically desert region that lacks replenishment provisions. Illinois financial problems were used as an example of the type of issue that might be solved by selling Great Lakes water. I had no idea this was going on and always thought the Great Lakes were sacred. 15. Annin directs the Burke Center for Freshwater Innovation at Northland College and Davis is a commissioner at Chicagos Metropolitan Water Reclamation District. More than 1,800 gigalitres of foreign-held water entitlements are within the Murray-Darling Basin, which is 9 . Quotes such as, Why are we allowing foreign corporations such as Nestle to make millions upon millions of dollars pumping water out of the Great Lakes and selling it overseas? This is not new news. In response to reader Peter and others, its true that there is no simple fix to the problem of extremely low (or high) water levels in the Great Lakes region. Gary Wilson. No. A safe money bet would be that another "ice age" will occure in the next 100,000 years, which will render the Nestle problem moot, a dozen time over. Chinese dams held back Mekong waters during drought, study finds With record high lake levels wreaking havoc around the region, Henderson noticed the proposed solutions by elected officials and the Army Corps of Engineers were focused on expensive deterrents like hard barriers. The International Joint Commission (IJC) approves and provides regulatory orders for projects that affect levels and flows on the other side of the international border. . Engineering or other solutions come with a big price tag and have yet to gain acceptance as feasible options. Surely we have the brain power, human ingenuity and spirit to do more than concern ourselves with territories and pacts of the past. Support the Coast Guard on the Great Lakes The Great Lakes covers a water area of more than 94,250 square miles and has a coastline shared with Canada of 10,900 miles. china stealing water from great lakes - homatrading.com The first sentence in my prior post should read Great Lakes Statenot simply state though I see comments are censored, forgive me, moderated so it is unlikely to matter. It's located at exactly a divergent plate boundary, having spread apart so significantly over time that the lake is up to 79 kilometers (49 miles) wide, and has three separate basins to it. At the time, veteran Great Lakes water activist Lynn Broaddus said this wont be the last of the profit-minded outsiders who want to tap the regions water. Illinois had problems paying the lottery winners. Lies About Obama Selling Great Lakes Water To China - YouTube This country benefits from sharing resources. I think someone might notice a project of this scale. Scientists Discover a Massive Underground Lake in China - Business Insider Mike Hardy is the owner of Thumbwind Publications LLC. Our federal government, first and foremost, must set the bar high and tackle these huge infrastructure problems like during the Roosevelt Era. Hendersons proposal follows a recent foray into tapping Great Lakes state water reserves. Most likely its 20+ times as much.one 3ft pipeline may work for oil, but how about 20 of them for water? They are composed of numerous aquifers (groundwater) that have filled with water over the centuries, waters that flow in the tributaries of the Great Lakes, and waters that fill the lakes themselves. An out-of-court settlement was reached in 2009. I don't doubt it since a glass of tap water costs what? And further east, similar things are happening. You also agree to this sites Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. Thats what scares those of us who are in the community studying this data pool.. Gary. It must not have anything to do with man made things, like a massive new water pipe line going into the southern states. How likely is the fear the West could steal Great Lakes water? In 2018 there was a public comment period in which over 80,000 Michigan residents submitted objections to a permit that allows Nestle to pump over half a million gallons of water a day from Michigan aquafers. Current water control structures at the outlets of Lakes Superior and Ontario do very little in controlling the overall supply of water in the basin. 2. A few diversions have been approved under the compact, including withdrawals from Lake Michigan by New Berlin and Waukesha in Wisconsin. Swiss Nestle is Stealing Great Lakes Water, Shipping it to China This overused inflammatory headline refers to the ability of companies to bottle water within the Great Lakes watershed. Images on this page may contain affiliate links in which we may receive a commission. Pepsi, Coca-Cola, Avita, and Nestle have been operating in Michigan and surrounding states for over 15 years. Great Lakes Water to Be Sold to China As Half of U.s. Faces Extreme D21, We better learn to like those carp. Its origins go back to concerns raised when opening the Great Lakes to international shipping in the 1950s. It is being projected that repairing and expanding our decaying drinking water infrastructure will cost more than one trillion dollars over the next 25 years, and as a result our water bills will likely approximately triple over that time period. (LogOut/ Scv$35.00 at the best online prices at eBay! If we assume a generous porosity of 10% in the Tarim Basinto 283 feet would contain about 1/3 of the water in the Great Lakes. The average annual depletion rate between 2000 and 2007 was more than twice that during the previous fifty years. this thing should be taken down immediately. OK.think about this..5.5 billion gallons per hour of water flows over Niagara Falls..that flow can be controlled..and a lot of that control at the falls is not for the upper lakes but for the St Lawrence seawaymoney profit can do god things.like fight the infiltration of Asian Carpthe lake levels can be controlledonce again .5.5 billion gallons per hour of water flowed over Niagara Fallsand you know what that potential revenue in the $$$$$$$ billions turns into ..SALT WATER. As of now, China has not joined the convention, representing a key blow to the UN's efforts. As much as half the world's water supply is being stolen, with agriculture responsible for much of that, according to a new study. Dave I suspect most in the region share your sentiments. Cameron Davis, who led the efforts of environmental groups to enact the compact, did not respond to a request for comment. One of the most toxic was drywall which contained sulfuric acid, why would you put sulfuric acid in drywall, many people were sickened from it. It started in 2009 as a fun-loving site covering Michigan's Upper Thumb. In low level periods, I doubt western states that have become dependent on the diverted water will be happy about having the spigot closed. Right now, the United States uses approximately 148 trillion gallons of fresh water a year, and there is no way that is sustainable in the long run. Since 2000, Nestle Waters North America sell bottled Spring Water marketed with the Ice Mountain label. It has been estimated that the state of New Mexico only has a 10 year supply of fresh water left. This Public Law 110-342 was introduced in the Senate by Carl Levin (D Michigan) on July 23, 2008, passed the Senate on August 1, 2008, by unanimous consent, passed the House of Representatives on September 23, 2008, and finally signed into law by President George W. Bush on October 3, 2008. The cost of sending water out west would have an enormous infrastructure cost. The 2008 pact that was created to safeguard the Great Lakes water supply has a provision that allows areas on the edge of the Great Lakes watershed to request diversions, but Waukesha is the first town to do so. Canada reviewed and approved the agreement. Water flows into Lake Powell, nestled between Utah and Arizona, from high in the Rocky Mountains via the Colorado River. For example, wildfires burned an astounding 3.6 million acres in the state of Texas alone during 2011. Look at past choices, responsible behavior and long-term sustainability. the following list of 15 facts about the coming water crisis is from one of my previous articles entitled Dust Bowl Conditions Are Literally Returning To The Western Half Of The United States. Correlation does not imply causation. Ask the Great Lakes Now Team Your PFAS Question, Beneath the Surface: The Line 5 Pipeline in the Great Lakes, Collection 1 An Exploration of the Great Lakes, Collection 2 Threats to the Great Lakes, Collection 3 Virtual Field Trips in the Great Lakes, Collection 4 Lesson Plans from Our Monthly PBS Program, Industries and public water supplies top list of main consumers of Great Lakes water, Question of Diversion: Great Lakes governors group silent on future water threats, Great Lakes Water Diversions Could Be More Numerous, Drinking Water News Roundup: Climate change and Illinois water withdrawals, clean water for Michigan students, Nestl Exit: North American bottled water brands sold to investment firm, Detroiters can get another 1,125 gallons of water under discount program, Charles Stewart Mott Foundation Partnership, U.S. Judge: Flint has 5 months to finish long-overdue lead pipe replacement, Hope springs eternal for Michigan legislator who champions drinking water equity. If Illinois is in debt, selling Michigans and Wisconsins share of Great Lakes water is no solution at all. The water would be treated at a Waukesha water plant and dumped into the Root River, where it would flow into Lake Michigan through Racine, Wisconsin. This would create quite a traffic jam at the Soo Locks! The University of Michigan estimates that approximately 100 million pounds of fish are harvested from the Great Lakes by commercial fishermen. Featured Image:The Sun sets on Lake Michigan, courtesy of Russell Sekeet via flickr.com cc 2.0. Record rainfall in the midwest over the last decade or two shows no signs of letting up. Corporate Partners . I already busted this myth in a previous post but will summarize it again here. One so-called expert noted, Lake Michigan water is being shipped by boat loads over to China! A single no vote would have scuttled the citys plan. The Great Lakes system includes five large lakes, one small lake, four connecting channels, and the St. Lawrence Seaway. The only dredging that occurs today is to keep rivers at authorized depths for navigation. Its true that the weather plays a major role in water level fluctuations. Its great ammo against the Blame Obama crowd. and a purchased bottle costs maybe 1,50-3,00sfr. I have a question. Staff, Thumbwind. Climate change may very well have forced us into a new normal and be irreversible. A Minnesota company floated the idea of shipping water from a Minnesota aquifer to Colorado via rail tanker for an undefined purpose. Math time! Hendersons legal specialty is in securities and banking regulation and economics. Third Rail Proposal: Selling Great Lakes water proposed to lower lake Water Levels of the Great Lakes Are Declining - Scientific American If you found your way to this article recently, you may have discovered it on Snopes or another mythbuster page. A public resource. I. Using the example from Lake Superior, even if each ship could carry 2.5 million gallons of water in bladder tanks, it would take more than 10,000 ships a day leaving Lake Superior to equal the amount of water lost to evaporation in one day. It will go down the drains and fill their rivers and ****s, kill all their fish. Re: Swiss Nestle is Stealing Great Lakes Water, Shipping it to China Well they do say the next oil will be water. Half Lie #5 The Great Lakes are Diverted Out West, Lie #6 The Waukesha & Foxconn Flip Flop, How Many Gallons of Water is In the Great Lakes? Lake Powell is draining due to climate change what does this mean for the local environment? The U.S. Supreme Court, in a 1967 consent decree, limited the Lake Michigan water diversion through the Chicago canal to 3,200 cubic feet of water per second. The president is now pushing for free trade with South Korea which I am totally against. Unable to reach a road-funding agreement with the legislature, Michigan Gov. It turns out that the Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy (EGLE) is powerless to stop the foreign company from proceeding with its pumping. So its like what we saw in the Dirty Thirties, but imagine the Dirty Thirties going on for 30 years. If the state water board approves the cease-and-desist order against BlueTriton, the company could face fines of up to $1,000 a day, or up to $10,000 a day if a drought is declared in the area. Experts have been quoted blaming the weather for low lake levels in everything from this blog to the New York Times and in NBC News reports, but as described in detail in a previous post about how climate change and variability drive water levels on the Great Lakes, just blaming the weather is not the full story. Let's not sweat the small stuff.. And organizations like the EPA and the State are wondering why water levels are at an all time low? Great Lakes ecoregion - National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration In 2004, China signed a multimillion-dollar fishing license agreement with North Korea that led to a drastic increase in the number of Chinese boats in North Korean waters. They just assume that there will always be plenty of fresh water for all of us to use just like there always has been. Causing them to now owe us large amounts of money they can never pay back. I dare say very few. CBC News Posted: Jun 23, 2016 6:00 AM ET Last Updated: Jun 23, 2016 6:00 AM ET, Richard Harvey, mayor of the town of Nipigon in northwestern Ontario, says he is very disappointed by the decision to allow Waukesha, Wis., to divert water from Lake Michigan. A company from Switzerland, Nestl, has been operating a water bottling plant in Michigan since 2000. INVESTOR TIMES is always open to the incorporation of talent in its team of journalists and editors. Estimates are that Lake Michigan holds one quadrillion (1,000,000,000,000,000) gallons of water. I bet next a bunch of Democrats will be mad at Obama. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. A recent report by the IJC states: Climate change poses new challenges for adapting to fluctuating Great Lakes water levels. From an engineering perspective and a geopolitical perspective, they are quite naive. Obama Sells Great Lakes Water To China 9,411 views Dec 17, 2013 With the United States as well as the rest of the world suffering from water drought, President Obama is allowing Ch. Clearly, residents object to the stealing of Great Lakes Water. For example, Californias Central Valley produces much of the food abundance we enjoy but needs water to do it, which is in short supply there. Free shipping for many products! Them Chinese got products at most all American stores does that count for stealing? Also, its a cheap rhetorical ploy to defend a practice based on your assertion that its been going on for years, is only half as bad now, is partially mitigated by some prior and completely unrelated offset. And when water levels drop and financial issues still abound, continue to sell this resource to pay the bills? (LogOut/ Communist China won Ronnie's Cold War and can have as much of our water as they want. NOAA last week forecast below-average precipitation for those regions this winter, meaning that after some relief during the past few months, the Southwests three-year drought is likely to redevelop and spread to the Southeast. (336) 667-3034. Lie #4 Foreign companies are pumping water out of the Great Lakes without limits.